Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Andrew's avatar

This might be a long one, and a bit late (after initial publish date), but here goes...

First off: I'm American.

Second: I've been a die-hard Gooner since Sept 03, so I started from the highest of highs and have mourned in the lowest of lows, but never did my love for the Gunners dwindle. It was just the same heartache I get when I see my kids (a deep love of mine) struggle to succeed or make bad decisions that have negative outcomes: I want to die from sorrow sometimes, but the love never dies. And the sorrow never lasts forever.

That said; Jonathan, sir, you are one of, if not THE, best writers I have ever read. I subscribed to The Athletic about 6 months before you started this blog and every time I saw your name in the comments, I knew I was going to spend the next 90-120 second reading someone who echoed my thoughts, but did so in such a breathtaking way that I moved on to the next comment (after liking yours) feeling like I had just finished reading a work on the level of Chaucer, or a little more recently, Tolkien; in that how you described certain plays or feelings or your own analysis of the match and then how you conveyed your opinion were all in such a way that I got lost in your comment: I was in the stadium, feeling the atmosphere, seeing the play (even if you yourself weren't in the stadium for that particular match that you were commenting on)...and I loved it. I loved reading the encouragement from other real fans (not the bandwagon, trolly, "Arteta out" in his 2nd season without giving him a chance to build "his" team) telling you to start writing on your own, or get a job writing for The Athletic (which I would love).

I read your first 2 articles right after they were posted, and then have drifted back from time to time, but I wanted to put this initial "greeting" on an article that I felt was right... and it was this one - 2 days after the season ended. I decided that I'm going to binge your articles over the next day or so when I get free time, and I wanted to leave a heartfelt thank you for your bravery in making yourself vulnerable at the cost (or reward I should say) of allowing other like-minded brothers and sisters to get lost in the incredible trappings of your mind as you write about and parallel the one thing we ALL have in common here: our never ending, never failing love of The Arsenal.

Expand full comment
Susie Mawhinney's avatar

As promised - I read this post and can’t deny being completely absorbed - Good grief you drive a hard pitch Jonathan - pun intended - anyone. capable of citing Keats in conjunction with a sport “being in uncertainties, mysteries, doubts, without any irritable reaching after fact and reason” as you did here has my attention - I’m tempted even to research further the history of Arsenal - Shhh, it’s definitely a secret though..!

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts